Steven Tyler - Say Whaaaat??

[marcy]

ashley- -steven tyler is crap...where has he been in the last 10 years? no where! how can you say he is good!

[MusicBoardBill999]

I agree, Steven Tyler on American Idol sounded a bit scary to me...I mean, what is going on? is the guy just bored and wants an easy paycheck or something?

My interest in American Idol waned a few years ago - Maybe a revamp with new judges is going to help it now - Look what I read yesterday - Not sure my feelings on this yet ...

Aerosmith confirms Tyler as American Idol judge
Is the rock n’ roll cat finally out of the bag for real, this time?

When it comes to Steven Tyler’s status as an American Idol judge, there’s been nothing official from the show’s producers, but reality TV’s worst-kept secret has now been confirmed three times in the past month by members of Aerosmith

[admin]

he is so messed up from all his drug use he doesnt know what he is doing!

[Multiple Cars Guy]

The guy is so burnt out. He can barely get a coherent sentence out.

[Skitz]

The guy is AWESOME! Like no joke, that dude is legit.

[nyhartp]

Yea, not sure how I felt about that...he'll still be back next year.

[superiorinferior]

Tyler I remember when you were in a band called Aerosmith and were actually cool.

[Mason]

Stephen has definitely revitalized the show giving it its best ratings in years. I think he has definitely livened up the show and made it more interesting. So far this season has been great and hilarious with Stephen's sense of humor. I really got out of watching Idol until Stephen came on board and know I'm as in to it as much as I was at the roots of the show.